This recipe is so simple and so rich and luxurious that it's become a holiday staple for our family. I've been making it for more decades than I'd like to admit.
I've tried a gazillion ways to make scalloped oysters over the years. I've tried recipes with eggs to make a pudding-like texture but prefer allowing the casserole to makes its own pudding like consistency, sans the eggs.
On occasion I've made this with half-and-half instead of straight cream and it's quite good, just a good deal lighter in flavor.
Most recipes out there will call for a pint of oysters for 4 people but I find a half-pint works just fine. The flavor is quite intense as is.
As many versions as I've tried over the years, none can compete with this, the simple and true original.
The good news about scalloped oysters is that the dish itself is so rich that a small amount goes a long way, making it defy its luxurious taste and end up as something of a frugal course. The flavor is intense enough to follow a rich soup. I'll often serve a savory pumpkin soup before the scalloped oyster course.
It can literally be thrown together in a few minutes. The crumbling of the saltines is something all kids seem to enjoy and is a great way to engage the younger cooks with more than just cookies in the kitchen. Start them young and let them realize the full benefit that basic cooking skills add to a life well-lived.
Some folks think I use fresh-shucked oysters but I have to admit that I'm the kind of gal who thinks that if I'm shucking any oyster I should be eating it right away. So for this tasty dish I generally stick with the jars of oysters available at just about any supermarket in America now. For a casserole, they work perfectly well.
You'll need:
half-pint jar of oysters
1/2 cup of cream
1 cup crumbled saltines
2 tablespoons butter, cut into bits
1 oz sherry
freshly grated nutmeg and salt/pepper to taste
Strain oysters, reserving their liquor. Return oyster liquor to the jar.
To a buttered casserole, add a tablespoon or two of crumbled saltines.
Top with half of the oysters and 1/2 the butter. Salt and pepper to taste. Dot with half of the butter bits.
Add 1/2 of the remaining saltines, layer the remaining oysters, and top with the remaining saltines. Salt and pepper this final layer to taste.
To the reserved liquor, add the sherry and freshly grated nutmeg, stir gently. Add enough cream to fill the jar and again stir gently.
Pour the liquor/cream mixture over the assembled oysters and crackers. Dot with remaining bits of butter. At this point, the casserole will look like a soupy mess.
Bake in 350 degree over for 30-40 minutes until browned but still soft in the center.
Serve immediately.