
Innkeepers have always had somewhat of a love/hate relationship with online review sites like
TripAdvisor and the like. If your guests post glowing reviews, you love the site. If you've been slammed by some that seem a bit unfair, well, it goes the other way.
For years now I've been hearing of innkeepers who follow up on bad reviews by burying them with positive reviews posted by friends and family. Heck, I've even heard of aspiring innkeepers learning to do this in some of those nifty aspiring innkeepers workshops. I know innkeepers who trade free nights at each other's inns and then follow up that freebie visit with a glowing review - knowing full well their friends will do the same for them.
My answer to the dilemma remains unchanged.
Do NOT under any circumstances post a fake review, of any kind. It will come back to bite you just where you don't want it to, just when you least expect it. Just do not go there.
And DON'T, I repeat don't, game the system by trading reviews with your friends. It's really not as cool a thing to do as you think it is. In fact, I'd say it is very uncool.
As a frequent traveler myself, I rely on TripAdvisor a lot. And maybe because as an innkeeper I've only gotten reviews of the glowing kind perhaps there's a bit of a bias.
But honestly, I've seen bad reviews that, as shocking and anger-filled as they were, I knew damn well were the truth. Why? Because I knew the innkeepers being reviewed a) didn't really care about their guests and b) were ill-suited to innkeeping altogether. If I know that you can bet that guests know it, too.
Are some guest reviews unfair? No doubt. Do some guests use the threat of bad online reviews to blackmail innkeepers into changing their stated policies? Yes, I'm afraid that does happen.
Have I seen reviews I thought were fake? Oh yeah. Lots of them. Good and bad. The bad always leave an innkeeper suspecting the competition and, I have to say I've seen some real ugliness on that front. The good fake reviews are often just mindbogglingly dumb and easy to dismiss. If you're going to have your brother in Alaska write up a fake review, it might not be a good idea for him to use his real name. Yes, I've actually seen that.
So as a traveler, I tend to dismiss the one-hit-wonders on TA for that very reason. I look at the totality of reviews - and the number of one-hit-wonders included - when I decide where to stay. One bad review, unless it includes an equally bad management response (do not get me started), won't usually sway me. In fact, if the management response is really good, it may win me over. I think I'm a typical guest in that regard.
But innkeeper frustration has taken, shall we say, a turn in the whole he-said-she-said game. Things are
shaking up in the UK on this with lawsuits getting ready to fly. IP addresses will fly, too. The scam, where there is one, will burst wide open:
Once the list is published, websites that feature user-generated content - such as TripAdvisor - will have to notify any reviewers on the list. They will be given two weeks to remove their comments. They could face legal action if they cannot prove that they visited the hotels or restaurants concerned.
Do go over and read the whole thing but here's the moneyquote:
Kwikchex’s Chris Emmins told The Telegraph: ‘‘People who leave these anonymous reviews, which can damage the reputation of both businesses and individuals, need to realise that not only can they be sued for libel but they can also face criminal prosecution.’
Here in the states, though, I still hear crazy comments from innkeepers who actually believe they cannot be sued for an anonymous post or for anything they say online.
Let me give my opinion on this for folks who have not been following this blog for a while: that is batshit insane. Yes, you can quote me on that.
As much as the online review sites try to maintain privacy, malicious and fraudulent reviews won't be protected by anyone. Be careful what you say. You are, indeed, liable for the damage your actions cause. If malicious and fraudulent actions can traced back to you, don't expect anonymity to save you.
Will the TA suit eventually come to the US? Yes, I think it will. Will folks who've written malicious reviews be outed? It's only a matter of time.
Will they be named and shamed as the UK story suggests? Some of them will, no doubt.
Your inn is your baby. Protect it like you would anything you cherish: with love and attention. There is no shortcut to providing impeccable service to guests.
And there's no shortcut to changing opinions either. Give it time and the truth will always win out.