That seems to be the basic premise among the we've-rounded-a-corner crowd. 2009 was so bad that 2010 can only be better.
And here's why they think 2009 was bad. Because it was.
RevPAR down a whopping 16.7% to 53.71
Occupancy down 8.7% to 55.1
ADR down 8.8% to 97.51
Or as the same folks who told us this fall that we've rounded a bend put it,
“Good riddance to 2009, a year which we believe will go down as the worst in the modern hotel industry,” said Mark Lomanno, president at STR. “The combination of a distressed economy in conjunction with panic pricing drove RevPARs down to levels that were virtually incomprehensible just a year and a half ago. I look for a significant improvement in the key hotel performance indicators in 2010.”
Well yeah, if it's the worst ever, it's not unlikely that the next year could be better.
Except for one little problem. It's the economy stupid.
Unemployment still crazy high. Check. Credit card rates at 30% all over the place. Check. Folks being told in commercials on the teevee that they should bargain down the hotel by 50%. Check. Foreclosures all over the place. Check. B&Bs on the market unlikely to sell at all. Check.
Which city suffered biggest drop? New York. How many NEW hotels opening there this year, adding rooms to an industry already struggling to fill the ones they have? 50
How about Houston? Bad. And lots of new hotels opening there in 2010, too.
And how is this year going so far?
What's that?
In year-over-year measurements, the industry’s occupancy ended the week virtually flat with an 0.8-percent decrease to 47.8 percent. Average daily rate dropped 7.4 percent to finish the week at US$94.78. RevPAR for the week fell 8.2 percent to finish at US$45.33.
Hmmmm. Looks like things are still not all that rosy, if you ask me.
So where do you get out of the reality of our situation that things will get better?
Well, you start with the premise that we've gone so far down that we can't go further. And then you start saying, well, not much further.
And then you finish with saying good riddance last year, hello blue skies.
Here's my prediction. Many many hotels will not make it through this year. Many many B&B owners will face tragedy as they age and simply cannot sell their inns. All the new rooms on the market from new hotels opening in major cities will force ADR down further, causing panic in both those cities and outlying areas, pushing ADR down further.
When ADR goes, RevPAR can't be far behind.
What about the inns that buck the trend? Oh they're out there. They're smart. They're savvy marketers. They're working their butts off on packages and incentives and new marketing programs. They'll make it. They are good values already and will work to make sure prospective guests know that.
But it's not going to be an easy year. And it's not going to be pretty to watch.
The only good news? PAII finally took that silly study off it's front page claiming just the opposite of reality was true, that occupancy had gone up. You remember, the study that looked at 2006 results but posted on their website all of 2009. Jeeeeez.
Yes, rainbows are lovely. But I still don't go running out looking for a pot of gold at the end of each one. I've got real work to do. We all do.